Human Rights Watch, a monitoring and advocacy organization, published its finding that “Israeli authorities are committing the crimes against humanity of apartheid and persecution” on 27 April 2021. Amnesty International, also an advocacy organization, followed on 1 February 2022 with a 280-page report that dates the system it describes to 1948. The Israeli group B’Tselem reached its own apartheid conclusion in January 2021, about 3 months before Human Rights Watch. An NGO Forum text issued in Durban on 3 September 2001 had already declared Israel “a racist, apartheid state,” and “apartheid state” is the phrase Human Rights Watch’s 2021 report set aside as “not defined in international law.”
Key Findings
- Human Rights Watch released “A Threshold Crossed” on 27 April 2021, and Amnesty International published “Israel’s Apartheid against Palestinians” on 1 February 2022, 280 days later (Human Rights Watch, 2021; Amnesty International, 2022).
- B’Tselem’s position paper of January 2021 concluded that “the bar for labeling the Israeli regime as apartheid has been met,” about 3 months before the Human Rights Watch report (B’Tselem, 2021).
- The NGO Forum Declaration issued at Durban on 3 September 2001 states in paragraph 162, “We declare Israel as a racist, apartheid state,” 20 years before the Human Rights Watch report (WCAR NGO Forum, 2001).
- The Durban Declaration that governments adopted on 8 September 2001 contains the word “Zionism” 0 times across the 153 pages of its official edition (World Conference against Racism, 2001).
- A peer-reviewed 2013 article in the European Journal of International Law found “strong grounds to conclude that a system of apartheid has developed in the occupied Palestinian territory,” 8 years before the Human Rights Watch report (Dugard and Reynolds, 2013).
When did Human Rights Watch and Amnesty first allege apartheid?
Human Rights Watch released “A Threshold Crossed” on 27 April 2021, stating on its Jerusalem-datelined page that “Israeli authorities are committing the crimes against humanity of apartheid and persecution.” Amnesty International published “Israel’s Apartheid against Palestinians” on 1 February 2022, 280 days later. The order usually given for the two organizations, Human Rights Watch in 2021 and Amnesty in 2022, matches the dates the documents themselves carry.
The cover of the Human Rights Watch report reads “APRIL 2021,” and the report carries ISBN 978-1-62313-900-1. Its landing page calls it “The 213-page report.” Counting the cover and annexes, the PDF runs to 224 pages. Its front matter states the organization’s mission: “We scrupulously investigate abuses, expose the facts widely, and pressure those with power to respect rights and secure justice.”
Amnesty International’s report carries the index number MDE 15/5141/2022 and runs to 280 pages. Its back cover reads “FEBRUARY 2022.” Its inside cover describes Amnesty as “a movement of 10 million people which mobilizes the humanity in everyone and campaigns for change so we can all enjoy our human rights.” By their own descriptions, both organizations are monitoring and advocacy bodies, and each finding is that body’s own conclusion.
The two documents make findings of crimes under international law. Neither is a declaration about the identity of a state. Human Rights Watch attributed its finding to conduct by “Israeli authorities.” Amnesty attributed an “institutionalized regime” to the state itself.
The wording differs, and so does the reach. The 280 days separate two claims of different scope, not one claim made twice. A section-by-section account of how each report builds its case is in what the apartheid reports argue.
Which human rights group reached the conclusion first, and when?
B’Tselem, the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories, a monitoring and advocacy organization, published a position paper in January 2021 concluding that “the bar for labeling the Israeli regime as apartheid has been met.” That was about 3 months before Human Rights Watch’s release of 27 April 2021. The paper’s text carries no date; its PDF title gives January 2021, and no captured page gives a day.
The premise holds that major human rights organizations adopted the term in 2021 and 2022, and the first of them in that window was Israeli. B’Tselem’s 8-page paper is titled “A regime of Jewish supremacy from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea: This is apartheid.” Its starting premise, in its own words, is that “More than 14 million people, roughly half of them Jews and the other half Palestinians, live between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea under a single rule.” That population figure is B’Tselem’s own framing count.
The paper defines apartheid in one sentence: “A regime that uses laws, practices and organized violence to cement the supremacy of one group over another is an apartheid regime.” Under its own headings it identifies 4 methods:
- immigration
- the taking of land
- restrictions on Palestinians’ freedom of movement
- the denial of political participation
It adds that “What defines apartheid is not statements but practice.”
This is a position paper, not a treaty analysis. It refers in general terms to “international conventions,” but it does not test the Apartheid Convention or Rome Statute definitions element by element. Its conclusion concerns “labeling” rather than the legal elements of a crime.
Its scope is the widest of the three documents published in 2021 and 2022: a single regime over the whole area, Israel and the occupied territories together. B’Tselem describes the paper as “a call for change.” Its last page states that the organization is “Supported primarily by funding from foreign states.”
Did Human Rights Watch actually call Israel an apartheid state?
Human Rights Watch’s April 2021 report states that it does not set out “to determine whether Israel is an ‘apartheid state’”, and it describes that phrase as “a concept that is not defined in international law.” Its finding concerns a crime committed by authorities. It places all 3 elements of that crime together only “In the OPT, including East Jerusalem.”
The question’s own wording, “an apartheid state,” is therefore a phrase the earlier of the two major international reports set aside in its text. The same sentence says the report does not “compare Israel with South Africa under apartheid.”
In place of that comparison, it applies a legal test drawn from the Apartheid Convention and the Rome Statute. The test has three parts: “an intent to maintain a system of domination by one racial group over another; systematic oppression by one racial group over another; and one or more inhumane acts, as defined, carried out on a widespread or systematic basis pursuant to those policies.”
The report draws a precise territorial line. Human Rights Watch writes that “the Israeli government has demonstrated an intent to maintain the domination of Jewish Israelis over Palestinians across Israel and the OPT.” Only in the occupied territory, it continues, “that intent has been coupled with systematic oppression of Palestinians and inhumane acts committed against them. When these three elements occur together, they amount to the crime of apartheid.” On the report’s own terms, the intent element reaches inside Israel and the full crime does not.
The report makes a second finding: “Israeli officials have also committed the crime against humanity of persecution.” It summarises the customary-law elements of persecution as “severe abuses of fundamental rights committed on a widespread or systematic basis” together with “discriminatory intent.” The abuses it lists are:
- “the widespread confiscation of privately owned land”
- “the effective prohibition on building or living in many areas”
- “the mass denial of residency rights”
- “sweeping, decades-long restrictions on the freedom of movement and basic civil rights”
How far back does Amnesty date the system it describes?
Amnesty International’s February 2022 report dates the system it describes to 1948. It writes that Israel “has established and maintained an institutionalized regime of oppression and domination of the Palestinian population for the benefit of Jewish Israelis.” It calls that regime “a system of apartheid,” in force “wherever it has exercised control over Palestinians’ lives since 1948.”
That finding reaches further than Human Rights Watch’s, made 280 days earlier, in both time and place. Amnesty’s scope covers Palestinians in Israel, in the occupied territory and, as refugees, outside both. It finds apartheid inside Israel as well as in the occupied territory, while Human Rights Watch found the full crime only in the occupied territory.
Amnesty applies 3 instruments, which it names as “the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (ICERD), the International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid (Apartheid Convention) and the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (Rome Statute).”
It examined 4 components of the system: “territorial fragmentation; segregation and control; dispossession of land and property; and denial of economic and social rights.” It found that the inhuman or inhumane acts it documented “amount to the crime against humanity of apartheid under both the Apartheid Convention and the Rome Statute.” It also states that “the State of Israel considers and treats Palestinians as an inferior non-Jewish racial group.”
| Feature | Human Rights Watch, April 2021 | Amnesty International, February 2022 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Where the full crime is found | Occupied territory, including East Jerusalem | Israel and the occupied territory | Human Rights Watch, 2021; Amnesty International, 2022 |
| Populations in scope | Palestinians in Israel and the occupied territory | Palestinians in Israel, the occupied territory and refugees outside both | Human Rights Watch, 2021; Amnesty International, 2022 |
| Instruments applied | Apartheid Convention, Rome Statute, customary law | ICERD, Apartheid Convention, Rome Statute (3 treaties) | Human Rights Watch, 2021; Amnesty International, 2022 |
| The phrase “apartheid state” | Set aside as “not defined in international law” | Writes “a system of apartheid” since 1948 | Human Rights Watch, 2021; Amnesty International, 2022 |
Both organizations concluded that Israeli authorities commit the crime of apartheid. They differ on where that crime is committed and since when.
Did NGOs call Israel an apartheid state before 2021?
The NGO Forum Declaration issued at Durban on 3 September 2001 states in paragraph 162: “We declare Israel as a racist, apartheid state.” That was 20 years before Human Rights Watch’s report. The forum met alongside the World Conference against Racism from 28 August to 1 September 2001, and its text describes itself as “the outcome of an international process before and during the NGO Forum.”
The full paragraph continues: “in which Israels [sic] brand of apartheid as a crime against humanity has been characterized by separation and segregation, dispossession, restricted land access, denationalization, ‘bantustanization’ and inhumane acts.”
Other paragraphs use related language:
- Paragraph 98 calls the occupation “colonialist, discriminatory” and refers to “other racist methods amounting to Israel’s brand of apartheid and other racist crimes against humanity.”
- Paragraph 160 calls for an end to “the Israeli systematic perpetration of racist crimes including war crimes, acts of genocide and ethnic cleansing.”
The accompanying Programme of Action calls “for the reinstitution of UN resolution 3379 determining the practices of Zionism as racist practices.” It also calls on the international community “to impose a policy of complete and total isolation of Israel as an apartheid state as in the case of South Africa.” The Programme’s paragraph numbers differ by 1 between surviving copies, so those two passages are identified here by their text.
The document’s status determines what it can show:
- The Conference never adopted it, and it is not a United Nations document.
- The forum had no continuing secretariat, and the Conference’s Secretary-General declined to commend the text to governments.
- No issuing body publishes it. Every readable copy sits on a third-party host, and 3 such copies were read on 19 August 2026.
- Its Declaration runs to roughly 194 paragraphs, and its Programme of Action runs past 470.
As a record, it establishes what forum participants wrote and circulated at Durban in 2001. It is the earliest dated NGO document using “apartheid state” about Israel among the sources examined here.
How did governments respond to the 2001 Durban language?
US Secretary of State Colin L. Powell withdrew the American delegation from the World Conference against Racism on 3 September 2001. He objected to “declarations containing hateful language,” including language that “suggests that apartheid exists in Israel.” Governments adopted their own Durban Declaration 5 days later, on 8 September 2001, after the American delegation had left.
The State Department published Powell’s full sentence as the United States’ own account of its decision: “I know that you do not combat racism by conferences that produce declarations containing hateful language, some of which is a throwback to the days of ‘Zionism equals racism;’ or supports the idea that we have made too much of the Holocaust; or suggests that apartheid exists in Israel; or that singles out only one country in the world, Israel, for censure and abuse.” He said he had acted “with regret, because of the importance of the international fight against racism.”
The Conference’s press release RD/D/27, dated 3 September 2001, is headed “United States, Israel Announce Withdrawal from Conference.” It records that “the United States and Israel announced that they were withdrawing their delegations from the Conference.” It also records that Conference President Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma and Secretary-General Mary Robinson “expressed regret over the withdrawal.”
The Israeli Foreign Ministry’s 2001 page on the Conference no longer resolves; as of 19 August 2026 it redirected to the ministry’s current landing page. Israel’s withdrawal therefore rests on the Conference’s own record.
Because the withdrawal came first, Powell’s words refer to draft and forum texts current on 3 September, not to the instrument adopted afterwards. The official UN edition of that adopted Declaration runs to 122 paragraphs, and the word “Zionism” appears 0 times across its 153 pages. Israel is named once in its operative Middle East paragraphs, in Declaration paragraph 63, which reads in full: “We are concerned about the plight of the Palestinian people under foreign occupation. We recognize the inalienable right of the Palestinian people to self-determination and to the establishment of an independent State and we recognize the right to security for all States in the region, including Israel, and call upon all States to support the peace process and bring it to an early conclusion;”
Did legal scholars apply the apartheid treaty test before 2021?
John Dugard and John Reynolds published a peer-reviewed article in the European Journal of International Law in 2013. It concluded that “there are indeed strong grounds to conclude that a system of apartheid has developed in the occupied Palestinian territory.” That was 8 years before Human Rights Watch’s report. The article reads the 1965, 1973 and 1998 instruments against Israeli law and practice in the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza.
The article is refereed legal argument. It counts and samples nothing.
On the group element, the authors write that “the interpretation of racial groups as developed in international law appears sufficiently broad to understand Jewish Israelis and Palestinian Arabs as distinct groups,” because “the question of racial groups is a sociological rather than a biological one.” That conclusion concerns the two groups in relation to each other, and the authors state it with the qualifier “appears.”
On the 1973 Apartheid Convention’s reference to apartheid “as practised in southern Africa,” they write that the Convention “was not intended to be confined to those circumstances.” Their territorial scope matches the area where Human Rights Watch would later find the full crime. Both the 2013 article and the 2021 report confine that finding to the occupied territory. The broader treaty question is examined in the apartheid definition under international law.
The article discloses its lead author’s position. Dugard’s author footnote records that he was Special Rapporteur on the human rights situation in the Occupied Palestinian Territory to the Commission on Human Rights and the Human Rights Council from 2001 to 2008, and a judge ad hoc of the International Court of Justice. He was writing on the mandate he had held.
The same journal issue carries a peer-reviewed reply, pages 915 to 928, titled “A Reply to John Dugard and John Reynolds” (Zilbershats, 2013). Zilbershats argues that the analysis conflates sovereign territory with belligerent occupation and sets aside the armed-conflict context. The two articles stand side by side in the 2013 record, and the treaty question they dispute is the one Human Rights Watch applied in 2021.
Did a UN body publish an apartheid report before the NGOs?
The Times of Israel reported on 17 March 2017 that Rima Khalaf, Executive Secretary of the UN Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia, had resigned. Her commission’s report concluding that Israel had established “an apartheid regime” had been withdrawn at the UN Secretary-General’s request. That was 4 years before Human Rights Watch’s report.
The Times of Israel names the report’s authors as Richard Falk and Virginia Tilley. The report was published in March 2017 and withdrawn within the same month. The newspaper’s headline placed “apartheid Israel” in quotation marks, attributing the phrase to the report rather than adopting it.
The withdrawal is the institutional record. Because the Secretary-General asked for the report to be withdrawn, it stands as a commissioned document that was retracted, not as a finding of the United Nations. Its conclusion belongs to its authors.
In the sequence of dated documents, the 2017 report falls:
- 16 years after the Durban NGO Forum text
- 4 years after the Dugard and Reynolds article
- just under 4 years before B’Tselem’s January 2021 paper
It is the one document in that sequence issued inside an intergovernmental body and then withdrawn by it. Its operative term, “an apartheid regime,” is the same noun B’Tselem’s 2021 definition turned on (“an apartheid regime”). It differs from the “apartheid state” phrasing of the 2001 forum text.
The account here rests on Israeli press reporting of the resignation and withdrawal, dated to the day of the resignation. The withdrawn report itself is named, not relied on, and none of its contents beyond the conclusion the newspaper quoted is carried here.
Did Israeli officeholders use the word before the NGO reports?
Yossi Sarid, a former Israeli minister, published a Haaretz column on 25 April 2008 titled “Yes, It Is Apartheid.” That was about 13 years before B’Tselem’s January 2021 paper. It applies the word in the present tense, and it was made after Sarid had left office.
Earlier uses in that record are warnings rather than descriptions:
- Yitzhak Rabin, 1976. In an interview recorded by his press secretary and first published in the documentary “Rabin: In His Own Words,” he warned that Israel could not hold “a million and a half [more] Arabs inside a Jewish state” over the long term “if we don’t want to get to apartheid.” The Times of Israel reported the remark on 25 September 2015. Rabin prefaced it, “this I ask really not be used.”
- Ehud Olmert, 2007. As prime minister, he told Haaretz on 29 November 2007 that Israel facing “a South African-style struggle for equal voting rights” would mean “the State of Israel is finished.” The word apartheid is not in his words. A Boston Globe headline of 30 November 2007 supplied it.
Later uses before 2021 mix the two forms:
- Ehud Barak, 2010. As defence minister, he told the Herzliya Conference in February 2010, as reported by Tablet, “If this bloc of millions of Palestinians cannot vote, that will be an apartheid state.” This is a conditional warning, and it uses the question’s exact phrase.
- Alon Liel, 2013. He told the Times of Israel on 21 February 2013 that the West Bank occupation “is a sort of Israeli apartheid.”
The most-circulated roster, Zachary Foster’s “15 Former Israeli Leaders Call it Apartheid” (Palestine Nexus, 2024), lists 14 entries under a title of fifteen. Checked entry by entry against its linked reporting on 23 September 2026, the Institute’s own reading sorts them as follows:
- 6 apply the word to present conditions.
- 2 are conditional warnings.
- 3 quote words that do not include “apartheid.”
- 1 is a journalist who held no office.
- 2 rest on provenance that could not be confirmed.
Every present-tense statement on the list was made after the speaker had left the office named. A full entry-by-entry check of the list is in the 14 named statements.
Methodology and limitations
The report draws on these types of source:
- The advocacy documents themselves. The Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International reports were captured in full, page and PDF, on 16 November 2026. B’Tselem’s position paper was captured as a PDF on the same day; its web page returned an error and was not captured. Each is labelled a monitoring or advocacy organization, using the mission statement printed in its own pages.
- An adopted intergovernmental instrument. The Durban Declaration was read from the official UN edition of 2002. The count of 0 occurrences of “Zionism” comes from a full-text search of that edition on 19 August 2026.
- The NGO Forum text. It was read from 3 third-party copies, and paragraphs 98 and 162 were confirmed word-identical across the copies by direct string search.
- A government statement. Powell’s 2001 statement comes from the State Department archive and is labelled as the United States’ own account.
- Peer-reviewed legal articles. Dugard and Reynolds, and Zilbershats, are refereed legal argument, not measurement.
- Israeli press reporting. The 2017 withdrawal account comes from the Times of Israel.
- The press record of officeholder statements, read directly on 23 September 2026, and an advocacy compilation, Foster (2024).
Dates are taken from the documents themselves. Human Rights Watch’s date of 27 April 2021 comes from its landing-page dateline, and Amnesty International’s date of 1 February 2022 comes from its document page. The 280-day interval is computed from those two dates. B’Tselem’s paper is dated to the month only, because no captured page carries a day.
The 6, 2, 3, 1 and 2 split of Foster’s roster is the Institute’s own reading of that page, not a count the page publishes. A 2002 Haaretz column by former attorney general Michael Ben-Yair could not be read in full, because Haaretz’s archive copy is paywalled after its opening paragraph. His dated use of the word is therefore taken from his signed op-ed of 10 February 2022.
The Dugard and Reynolds article is paired throughout with its published rebuttal. Its lead author’s former UN mandate is stated where the article is used.
Conclusion
So when did the claim begin? Human Rights Watch published its finding on 27 April 2021 and Amnesty International on 1 February 2022, with B’Tselem’s position paper about 3 months ahead of both. The phrase “apartheid state” was on paper at Durban on 3 September 2001, in an NGO Forum text that the governments meeting there never adopted.
The years between are not empty:
- A peer-reviewed article tested the treaty definitions against the occupied territory in 2013.
- A UN regional commission’s report reached “an apartheid regime” in 2017 and was withdrawn within the month.
- A former Israeli minister titled a 2008 column “Yes, It Is Apartheid.”
The two major reports also stand apart from the phrase in the question. Human Rights Watch set “apartheid state” aside as undefined in law and found the full crime only in the occupied territory. Amnesty found a system reaching inside Israel and dated it to 1948. The governments at Durban, meanwhile, adopted a text in which “Zionism” appears 0 times.
What changes when a public argument dates “apartheid” to 2021? That date marks the arrival of crime findings that explicitly applied treaty definitions. A phrase that had already circulated for 20 years, in a text no government adopted, and in the words of former officeholders speaking after their terms had ended, is a different thing. Whether a debate is about a legal finding with stated limits or about a label with a longer and looser history is a question each citation in it answers, one date at a time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the adopted Durban Declaration mention antisemitism?
Yes. Declaration paragraph 61 of the World Conference against Racism (2001) records “deep concern” at “the increase in anti-Semitism and Islamophobia in various parts of the world.” Paragraph 58 reads, in full, “We recall that the Holocaust must never be forgotten;”. The printed spelling in the official edition is hyphenated, as quoted.
Was the 1973 Apartheid Convention written only for southern Africa?
Dugard and Reynolds (2013) read its “as practised in southern Africa” wording as reflecting “prevailing circumstances in southern Africa” without being “intended to be confined to those circumstances.” Zilbershats (2013), in the same journal issue, contests the article’s application to the occupied territory on other grounds, chiefly the distinction between sovereign territory and belligerent occupation.
What does the adopted Durban Declaration say about refugees?
Declaration paragraph 65 (World Conference against Racism, 2001) reads: “We recognize the right of refugees to return voluntarily to their homes and properties in dignity and safety, and urge all States to facilitate such return;”. Paragraph 64 calls for a peace “in which all peoples shall co-exist and enjoy equality, justice and internationally recognized human rights, and security;”.
Did B’Tselem compare Israel with South Africa?
B’Tselem (2021) wrote that “There are, of course, differences between the regimes,” noting that “the division in South Africa was based on race and skin color, while in Israel it is based on nationality and ethnicity.” It grounds its use of the term in a regime’s “organizing principle” rather than in the South African case.
Why can a citation to “Durban paragraph 63” point to two different texts?
The adopted Declaration and the Programme of Action each have their own paragraph 63 (World Conference against Racism, 2001). Declaration paragraph 63 concerns the Palestinian people and Israel’s security. Programme of Action paragraph 63 encourages business-sector codes of conduct “with a view to preventing trafficking in persons.”
Did Michael Ben-Yair use the phrase “apartheid regime” in 2002?
That is unconfirmed here: Haaretz’s archive copy of his column of 3 March 2002, “The War’s Seventh Day,” is paywalled after its opening paragraph, so the full text could not be read. His dated use of “an apartheid regime” read in full is a signed op-ed in TheJournal.ie on 10 February 2022, as recorded in the press record of officeholder statements.
Sources
- Amnesty International, 2022. Israel’s Apartheid against Palestinians: Cruel system of domination and crime against humanity. Index MDE 15/5141/2022. https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/mde15/5141/2022/en/. Monitoring or advocacy organization (subject document).
- B’Tselem, 2021. A regime of Jewish supremacy from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea: This is apartheid. Position paper, January 2021. https://www.btselem.org/sites/default/files/publications/202101_this_is_apartheid_eng.pdf. Monitoring or advocacy organization (subject document).
- Dugard, J. and Reynolds, J., 2013. Apartheid, International Law, and the Occupied Palestinian Territory. European Journal of International Law 24(3), 867 to 913. DOI 10.1093/ejil/cht045. Peer-reviewed.
- Foster, Z., 2024. 15 Former Israeli Leaders Call it Apartheid. Palestine Nexus, 18 August 2024. https://palestinenexus.com/articles/15-former-israeli-leaders-call-it-apartheid. Advocacy compilation.
- Human Rights Watch, 2021. A Threshold Crossed: Israeli Authorities and the Crimes of Apartheid and Persecution. ISBN 978-1-62313-900-1. https://www.hrw.org/report/2021/04/27/threshold-crossed/israeli-authorities-and-crimes-apartheid-and-persecution. Monitoring or advocacy organization (subject document).
- Statements by former Israeli officeholders using “apartheid”, as reported, 2007 to 2026. Haaretz, Boston Globe, Tablet, Times of Israel, TheJournal.ie, Associated Press and France 24, read 23 September 2026. Press record.
- Times of Israel, 2017. Head of UN body resigns as her group’s “apartheid Israel” report is withdrawn. 17 March 2017. Israeli press.
- US Department of State, 2001. World Conference Against Racism, statement by Secretary Colin L. Powell. 3 September 2001. https://2001-2009.state.gov/secretary/former/powell/remarks/2001/4789.htm. Official record (US government statement).
- WCAR NGO Forum, 2001. NGO Forum Declaration and Programme of Action. Issued 3 September 2001. https://i-p-o.org/racism-ngo-decl.htm. Primary artifact of advocacy discourse.
- World Conference against Racism, 2001. Durban Declaration and Programme of Action. A/CONF.189/12, official UN edition 2002. https://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/Durban_text_en.pdf. Official record (adopted intergovernmental instrument).
- World Conference against Racism, 2001. Press release RD/D/27, “United States, Israel Announce Withdrawal from Conference.” 3 September 2001. Official record (conference press release).
- Zilbershats, Y., 2013. Apartheid, International Law, and the Occupied Palestinian Territory: A Reply to John Dugard and John Reynolds. European Journal of International Law 24(3), 915 to 928. DOI 10.1093/ejil/cht043. Peer-reviewed.
