Paragraph 11 of UN General Assembly Resolution 194 (III), adopted on 11 December 1948, is the text the Palestinian return claim rests on. It says refugees “wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date,” and it adds compensation for those choosing not to return.
That sentence raises a question that has followed the refugees and their descendants ever since: did the Assembly promise a way home, or recommend one? The record divides along that line. In 1974 the Assembly’s Resolution 3236 called return an “inalienable right” and was adopted by 89 votes to 8. In 2009 Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, a party to the dispute, stated that “No such right exists under international law.” The 1995 Interim Agreement, which both parties signed, deferred “refugees” to permanent status talks due to begin by 4 May 1996.
Key Findings
- On 11 December 1948, paragraph 11 of Resolution 194 (III) said refugees wishing to return “should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date.” It also said compensation “should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return” (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975).
- On 22 November 1974, Resolution 3236 reaffirmed “the inalienable right of the Palestinians to return.” It was adopted by roll call, 89 votes to 8 with 37 abstentions, among the 134 delegations recording a position (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975).
- On 7 September 1949, the Conciliation Commission’s Technical Committee on Refugees estimated approximately 711,000 “refugees from Israel-controlled territory.” The figure is an estimate, not a census (United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1950).
- The Commission’s Refugee Office valued abandoned land at £P100 million as at 29 November 1947. The estimate was made in September 1951 and reported in 1961 (United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1961).
- On 30 December 2009, Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated its own position as a party to the dispute: “No such right exists under international law” (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2009).
Why is Resolution 194 the anchor of the return claim?
The General Assembly adopted paragraph 11 of Resolution 194 (III) on 11 December 1948, and it is the source text of the return claim. It resolves that refugees “wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date.” The same sentence pairs return with compensation (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975).
The compensation clause continues without a break. Compensation “should be paid for the property of those choosing not to return and for loss of or damage to property which, under principles of international law or in equity, should be made good by the Governments or authorities responsible.” The text attaches compensation to two separate losses: property left behind by those who do not return, and loss of or damage to property generally. Return and compensation sit in one provision. The text does not frame compensation as a price a refugee pays to give up return.
The sentence as adopted does not use the word “right.” By 7 December 1973, Resolution 3089 D (XXVIII) referred to the refugees’ “right to return to their homes and property, recognized by the General Assembly in resolution 194 (III).” On 22 November 1974, paragraph 2 of Resolution 3236 (XXIX) “Reaffirms also the inalienable right of the Palestinians to return to their homes and property from which they have been displaced and uprooted, and calls for their return.” The verb “reaffirms” presents the 1974 text as restating an existing position. The phrase “their homes” appears in both resolutions and links them textually.
The verbatim record of the 2296th plenary meeting records the 1974 vote. Resolution 3236 was adopted by roll call “by 89 votes to 8, with 37 abstentions” (A/PV.2296, paragraph 110). That gives the following shares of the 134 delegations recording a position, computed from the recorded vote:
- in favour: 66.4%
- against: 6.0%
- abstaining: 27.6%
These are shares of delegations voting, not of the full membership. A separate resolution adopted at the same meeting, 3237, had a different and wider opposition, and the two votes are never combined.
So the claim that Resolution 194 is the foundational UN reference for return holds up in the Assembly’s own texts. The 1948 paragraph provides the words “their homes,” and the Assembly’s resolutions of 1973 and 1974 add the word “right.”
Who reads paragraph 11 as a right, and since when?
The General Assembly itself has read return as a right since at least 7 December 1973, when Resolution 3089 D (XXVIII) called the refugees’ “right to return to their homes and property” one “recognized by the General Assembly in resolution 194 (III).” Resolution 3236 of 22 November 1974 called it “the inalienable right of the Palestinians to return to their homes and property.” The 1948 paragraph’s “should be permitted” contains no such language (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975).
In 1975 the Assembly built machinery around that reading. Resolution 3376 (XXX) was adopted on 10 November 1975 at the 2399th plenary meeting. It:
- established the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People, “composed of twenty Member States”;
- asked the Committee to recommend “a programme of implementation” for the rights in paragraphs 1 and 2 of Resolution 3236;
- told the Committee to report “no later than 1 June 1976”;
- asked the Security Council to consider the question “as soon as possible after 1 June 1976.”
A UN publication by outside scholars then extended the reading. In 1979 the United Nations published, at the Committee’s request, a study by W. Thomas Mallison and Sally V. Mallison titled “An International Law Analysis of the Major United Nations Resolutions Concerning the Palestine Question.” It reads the phrase “their homes and property” in Resolution 3236 as covering both the State of Israel and the territories occupied since 1967. The study carries the note “The views expressed are those of the authors” (Mallison and Mallison, 1979). It is the authors’ legal argument, not an analysis by the UN Secretariat.
Outside the UN record, one case is made in moral philosophy rather than law. Victor Tadros, Professor of Criminal Law and Legal Theory at the University of Warwick, made it in the peer-reviewed journal Politics, Philosophy & Economics (Tadros, 2017). He argues three things:
- Palestinians hold a right to return to the territory governed by Israel;
- the current generation retains a significant interest in return;
- their rights are not diminished in proportion as that interest is diminished.
The same article separates the right from any obligation. Its published abstract states: “However, it does not defend the duty on Israel to permit return. Whether there is such a duty depends on whether the economic, social and security costs override that right.” The holders of the rights reading, by name and date, are:
- the Assembly from 1973 at the latest;
- its Committee from 1975;
- the Mallisons in 1979;
- Tadros in 2017, who argues for a right while stopping short of a duty.
Which conditions does paragraph 11 attach to return?
Paragraph 11 of Resolution 194, adopted on 11 December 1948, attaches 3 conditions to return (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975):
- the refugee must be “wishing to return”;
- the refugee must “live at peace with their neighbours”;
- return happens “at the earliest practicable date.”
The operative verb, “should be permitted,” and a separate compensation standard complete the sentence.
Wishing to return. The first condition makes return a matter of the refugee’s choice. The same sentence confirms that the choice works in both directions by referring to “those choosing not to return,” who are owed compensation for their property instead.
Live at peace. The second condition sets a standard of conduct. It does not say who assesses that conduct or how.
Earliest practicable date. The third condition sets timing by feasibility rather than by a calendar date.
Who permits, and who pays. The verb “should be permitted” does not name the body that is to do the permitting. Compensation is owed “under principles of international law or in equity” by “the Governments or authorities responsible,” a phrase that names no government.
The 1974 text reads differently on each of these points.
| Element | Resolution 194, para 11 (1948) | Resolution 3236, para 2 (1974) |
|---|---|---|
| Operative verb | “should be permitted” | “Reaffirms … the inalienable right” and “calls for their return” |
| Peace condition | “live at peace with their neighbours” | None in the paragraph |
| Timing | “at the earliest practicable date” | None in the paragraph |
| Destination | “their homes” | “their homes and property from which they have been displaced and uprooted” |
| Compensation | Owed by “the Governments or authorities responsible” | None in the paragraph |
Source: United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975, adopted texts A/RES/194(III) and A/RES/3236(XXIX).
The 1974 paragraph has no peace condition and no timing qualifier. Its verbs are “reaffirms” and “calls for” rather than “should be permitted.” Both texts are resolutions of the General Assembly, not of the Security Council. The question of whether paragraph 11 carries binding force starts from two facts: the differences in wording between the two texts, and the fact that both came from the same organ.
What did the Conciliation Commission do to implement paragraph 11?
The Conciliation Commission’s Technical Committee on Refugees estimated approximately 711,000 “refugees from Israel-controlled territory” in a report dated 7 September 1949. The Commission published the estimate in its 1950 General Progress Report (United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1950). The Committee had considered a census and concluded that one was not advisable. It described the estimate as only “as accurate as circumstances permit.”
Resolution 194 also instructed the Commission to facilitate the repatriation, resettlement and economic and social rehabilitation of the refugees, and the payment of compensation. The Commission’s early counting work therefore defined the population that paragraph 11 addressed.
The Technical Committee’s figure has three limits:
- It sits below the relief rolls. The relief rolls carried a higher number than 711,000. The Committee attributed the difference to duplicated ration cards, people displaced from areas other than those held by Israel, and people who were destitute without having been displaced.
- It records origin, not cause. It counts refugees from Israel-controlled territory and does not say why anyone left.
- It excludes internal displacement. It does not count people displaced inside Israel.
The publisher’s description of Michael Fischbach’s 2003 Columbia University Press history gives a separate figure: “more than 726,000 Palestinians.” That figure comes from a different count and is not merged with the Commission’s estimate (Fischbach, 2003).
The Commission next turned to property claims. Its Secretariat issued a working paper on 12 April 1951, titled “Sampling Survey of Abandoned Property Claimed by Arab Refugees” (United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1951). The survey drew on fact-sheets that the relief agency had issued to 84,000 heads of refugee families in Jordan, about 540,000 people, and took samples of 400. It found:
- 34% of families (28,600) claimed no property;
- 66% (55,400) claimed buildings, land or both;
- the claimed land totalled 3,508,540 dunums.
The document disagrees with itself on houses. Its text says 49,500 families claimed houses, while its table totals 49,000. Its own caveat reads: “It must be noted that the claims on which the survey is based were unchecked and not documented.”
These figures cover Jordan only. They record what claimants stated, not what was verified or awarded.
What became of the compensation paragraph 11 promised?
The Conciliation Commission’s Refugee Office valued the abandoned land that “has passed to Jewish hands” at £P100 million. The estimate was made in September 1951 and reported in the Commission’s Historical Survey of 2 October 1961 (United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1961). The Office valued the land as at 29 November 1947, a date the survey elsewhere calls “the last date before the exodus of refugees when land values in Palestine were reasonably stable.”
Annex V of the 1961 survey gives the extent and the exact value:
- Extent: 16,324 square kilometres, of which 4,574 were cultivable.
- Rural lands: £P69,525,144.
- Urban lands outside Jerusalem: £P21,608,640.
- Jerusalem lands: £P9,250,000.
- Total: £P100,383,784, “or, say 100,000,000.”
The body of the survey also prints a rounded set of components. The exact set is used here throughout.
The method is set out in the Office’s own words. It rejected the records of Israel’s Custodian of Absentee Property, because “it was felt that it would be inappropriate to assess compensation entirely on the basis of information furnished by an interested party.” It built the land extent instead from the Mandatory government’s “Village Statistics 1945.” Values came from Mandatory property-tax assessments combined with expert opinion. The Office warned that its estimates “must inevitably be regarded as approximate ones.”
The 1961 survey also records a payment figure that is not compensation for property. Release of blocked Arab refugee bank accounts in Israel began in the summer of 1953 at the Palestine branches of Barclay’s Bank and the Ottoman Bank. “By 31 August 1956 a total of £2,633,175 of the accounts had been released.” That sum was a release of the refugees’ own frozen balances. It is a different object from the £P100 million valuation, and the two are never added together.
Later scholarship has revisited the Commission’s valuation:
- Lewis (2007). Economist Frank D. Lewis of Queen’s University valued urban property from transfer prices, tax payable and inferences about rent. His peer-reviewed abstract states: “The estimated value of the property is much higher than was reported by the United Nations Conciliation Commission in 1951” (Lewis, 2007).
- Fischbach (2003). Fischbach’s history of the refugee property question, based largely on archival records including the Commission’s, publishes previously secret UN estimates of the scope and value of the refugee property, in its publisher’s description (Fischbach, 2003).
How did Israel’s 1950 property law meet paragraph 11?
The Knesset enacted the Absentee Property Law in March 1950, fifteen months after paragraph 11 was adopted. It enacted the Development Authority (Transfer of Property) Law in July 1950. Both dates come from Geremy Forman and Alexandre Kedar’s peer-reviewed archival legal history (Forman and Kedar, 2004). Together the two statutes governed the property of everyone the law classed as an absentee.
The definition carried a date from before the war. Forman and Kedar summarise it: “An absentee was anyone who, on or after 29 November 1947 (the date of the United Nations General Assembly resolution to partition Palestine), had been: (a) a citizen or subject of one of the Arab countries at war with Israel; (b) in any of these countries, or in any part of Palestine outside the jurisdiction of the regulations; or (c) a citizen of Palestine who abandoned his or her normal place of residence.”
The authors place that date in the 1948 Absentee Property Regulations. The Absentee Property Law of 1950 replaced the Regulations with a permanent law, which the authors say included “notable changes” while keeping the 1948 framework and terminology.
The definition also reached people who remained inside Israel. Forman and Kedar write: “The result was that practically no Jewish Israelis, but tens of thousands of Arab Israeli citizens, were classified as absentees, assuming the paradoxical legal identity of ‘present absentee’.”
The statutes also fixed where the property could go. “The Absentee Property Law empowered the CAP to sell land to the DA alone, and the Development Authority Law empowered the DA to sell land to the state and the JNF.” The Development Authority was an intermediary body, legally defined as extragovernmental. In the first year of the 1953 Land Acquisition Law, some 1.2 million dunams were expropriated, of which 704,000 were taken from the Custodian. The 704,000 is part of the 1.2 million, not an addition to it. In late July 1960 the Knesset brought state, Development Authority and Jewish National Fund holdings together as “Israel Lands,” under a single administration.
The record does not give a total. Forman and Kedar write: “There is no one agreed-upon figure for the land that moved from Arab hands to the state in the wake of 1948.” They publish no total for the land that passed through the absentee-property system.
What does Israel’s government say Resolution 194 created?
Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs set out its own position, as a party to the dispute, on 30 December 2009: “No such right exists under international law, not has one been created by the relevant UN resolutions or the agreements between Israel and its Arab neighbors.” The statement appears in the Ministry’s question-and-answer document “Israel, the Conflict and Peace,” under the question “Do Palestinian refugees have a justifiable ‘right of return’?” (Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2009).
The document is the published position of a party to the dispute, not a finding by an outside body.
The Ministry’s reasoning is demographic. It cites its own round figures for 2009: a population of “approximately 7 million (of whom about one-fifth are Arab-Israelis).” It then states that “the influx of millions of Palestinians into the State of Israel would threaten the existence of Israel as a Jewish state, obliterating its basic identity as the homeland of the Jewish people and a refuge for persecuted Jews worldwide.” Those population figures are the Ministry’s 2009 estimates and are not a current count. The document gives no projected population share under return. It asserts the consequence without computing it.
The document characterises the return demand directly: “the demand to ‘return’ to Israel is nothing more than a euphemism for the demographic destruction of the Jewish state.” It also addresses later generations: “Under present conditions, the influx of a large number of descendents of refugees into Israel is not a viable option.” The spelling “descendents” is the document’s own, as is “not has one” in the sentence quoted above.
The Ministry’s Principle 2 names a different destination from paragraph 11: “While Palestinian refugees should be free to settle in the Palestinian homeland, Israel cannot allow itself to be demographically engulfed by a flood of refugees, undermining the basic identity of Israel as the world’s only Jewish state.”
Read beside the 1948 text, the 2009 statement differs from it on three points:
- Destination. Paragraph 11 says refugees are to return to “their homes.” Principle 2 says “the Palestinian homeland.”
- Legal status. Resolution 3236 calls return an “inalienable right.” The Ministry says “No such right exists.”
- Descendants. The Ministry addresses them explicitly. The 1948 sentence does not mention them.
Where did the 1995 interim agreement leave the refugee question?
The Interim Agreement that Israel and the PLO signed on 28 September 1995 listed “refugees” among the permanent status issues. Under Article XXXI(5), negotiations on those issues were to begin “as soon as possible, but not later than May 4, 1996” (Israel and the PLO, 1995). The text cited here is the English version published by Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, a party to the agreement.
The United States, the Russian Federation, Egypt, Jordan, Norway and the European Union witnessed the signing.
The agreement keeps refugees outside the interim arrangements. Article XVII(1) excludes from the Palestinian Council’s jurisdiction “Jerusalem, settlements, specified military locations, Palestinian refugees, borders, foreign relations and Israelis.” Article XXXI(5) lists the subjects of the permanent status talks: “Jerusalem, refugees, settlements, security arrangements, borders, relations and cooperation with other neighbors, and other issues of common interest.” Refugees therefore appear in both lists, once in the list of matters excluded from the Council’s authority and once in the list of matters deferred to later negotiation.
Article XXXI(6) preserves both parties’ positions: “Nothing in this Agreement shall prejudice or preempt the outcome of the negotiations on the permanent status to be conducted pursuant to the DOP. Neither Party shall be deemed, by virtue of having entered into this Agreement, to have renounced or waived any of its existing rights, claims or positions.”
The clause applies to both parties. On its terms, neither party renounced or waived, by signing, any existing right, claim or position, including any it held on paragraph 11.
The 4 May 1996 date is the deadline the parties agreed to. It records what the parties undertook to do, not what happened afterwards, and the instrument itself is not a record of whether the talks began or concluded. On its own terms, the signed agreement did not resolve the refugee question. It placed the question on a list for later negotiation and stated that neither party had given up its claims by signing.
Where do legal scholars split on paragraph 11’s force?
Three named works published between 2012 and 2018 frame the scholarly dispute over paragraph 11. The earliest is Andrew Kent’s 2012 article in the University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law. It asks whether Israel violated international law during the 1947 to 1949 conflict by expelling Palestinian civilians, or later by refusing to repatriate refugees (Kent, 2012).
Kent wrote a doctrinal legal argument. He measures nothing. His factual premises about 1947 to 1949 are assumed for the sake of argument rather than established. The journal is a student-edited US law review, not a peer-reviewed publication. His question is legal: whether international law in force at the time required repatriation. That is a different question from what a General Assembly resolution recommended.
Tadros (2017) makes a different kind of argument, in a different field. It is peer-reviewed moral philosophy, not law. He argues that Palestinians hold a right to return. He then states that his article “does not defend the duty on Israel to permit return,” because such a duty depends on whether “the economic, social and security costs override that right.” On descendants, his 2017 abstract argues that the current generation retains a significant interest in return. A later article argues that descendants can acquire occupancy rights through inheritance (Tadros, 2020).
The disagreement over facts that Kent sets aside was argued out directly at a Hebrew University of Jerusalem workshop on 14 to 15 December 2016. The rapporteur’s summary was published in 2018 (Israel Law Review, 2018). In the first session, as summarised, Benny Morris said Israel had maintained the refugee figure was 500,000, Arab countries had claimed nearer 900,000 or one million, and the UN concluded in 1949 to 1950 that the real figure was “just over 700,000.” In the same session, as summarised, Mahmoud Yazbak said “about 400 Palestinian towns and villages were destroyed, resulting in the expulsion and flight of about 80 per cent of the residents.” The proceedings are not a peer-reviewed article.
| Work | Kind of work | What it addresses |
|---|---|---|
| Kent, 2012 | Law review article, not peer-reviewed | Whether expulsion or non-repatriation in 1947 to 1949 violated international law |
| Tadros, 2017 | Peer-reviewed moral philosophy | A persisting right of return, held separate from any duty on Israel |
| Israel Law Review, 2018 | Workshop proceedings, rapporteur’s summary | Opposed accounts of the 1948 displacement, in one session |
Source: Kent (2012); Tadros (2017); Israel Law Review (2018).
These three works treat paragraph 11 as three different questions: a legal question, a moral question and a historical question. Each disagreement sits in a different field.
Methodology and limitations
The evidence comes from four types of source, ranked by the Institute’s evidence hierarchy.
Primary and official records:
- the adopted texts of General Assembly resolutions 194 (III), 3089 D (XXVIII), 3236 (XXIX), 3237 (XXIX) and 3376 (XXX), with the roll-call vote recorded in A/PV.2296, paragraph 110;
- three documents of the UN Conciliation Commission for Palestine, from 1950, 1951 and 1961;
- the Israel-PLO Interim Agreement of 1995, in the text published by Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs;
- that Ministry’s 2009 question-and-answer document, which states a party’s own position.
Peer-reviewed research:
- Forman and Kedar (2004), read in full;
- Lewis (2007) and Tadros (2017), both read from their published abstracts only, so no figure from the body of either article is cited.
Scholarly book: Fischbach (2003) is cited only for the figure in the publisher’s description, because the full text was not read.
Other works: Kent (2012) is a student-edited law review article. The Israel Law Review (2018) item is a rapporteur’s summary of a workshop. Mallison and Mallison (1979) is a UN-published study that carries the authors’ own views.
The Conciliation Commission’s figures are estimates by its own description. The 711,000 is an expert estimate, not a census. The 1951 property survey covers refugees in Jordan only, extrapolates from samples of 400, and rests on claims its authors call “unchecked and not documented.” The £P100 million valuation is described by the Refugee Office itself as approximate.
Several figures conflict, and each is reported separately rather than reconciled:
- The 1951 survey gives 49,500 house-claiming families in its text and 49,000 in its table.
- The Commission’s 711,000 and the 726,000 in the publisher’s description of Fischbach’s book come from different counts.
- Forman and Kedar record that no agreed figure exists for land that passed from Arab ownership to the state.
Conclusion
So did the Assembly promise a way home or recommend one? On the record, paragraph 11 of 11 December 1948 recommended one, in the words “should be permitted,” subject to three conditions. Twenty-six years later, by a recorded vote of 89 to 8, the Assembly described return as an “inalienable right” in a text with no peace condition and no timing qualifier.
The surrounding record follows the same split. The Conciliation Commission estimated 711,000 refugees and valued their land at £P100 million. It also deliberately set aside the Custodian’s records as coming from “an interested party.” Israel’s Absentee Property Law of March 1950 placed that property in a statutory chain ending in “Israel Lands” in 1960. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs, speaking for a party to the dispute in 2009, wrote that no right of return exists. The Interim Agreement the two parties signed in 1995 listed refugees for talks due by 4 May 1996 and preserved both parties’ positions. Scholars have treated the question in separate legal, moral and historical works.
A single sentence from 1948 has carried a recommendation, a right, a property valuation, a statute book and a deferred negotiating item. If the meaning of paragraph 11 has changed with each body that took it up, what would it take for any of those readings to become the settled one?
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Resolution 194 mention the descendants of refugees?
The adopted text of paragraph 11 refers to “refugees” and “their homes” and does not mention descendants (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975). Tadros argues in his 2017 article that the current generation retains a significant interest in return, and in his 2020 article that descendants can acquire occupancy rights through inheritance and bequest.
Why did Israel and the United States vote against Resolution 3236?
The recorded vote in A/PV.2296 lists 8 votes against: the United States, Bolivia, Chile, Costa Rica, Iceland, Israel, Nicaragua and Norway (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975). The verbatim record gives the roll call, not each state’s reasons.
What else did the Assembly adopt alongside Resolution 3236?
At the same 22 November 1974 meeting, Resolution 3237 invited the PLO to take part in the Assembly’s work “in the capacity of observer.” It was adopted by 95 votes to 17 with 19 abstentions (United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975). This was a different vote with a wider opposition, and it is not combined with the vote on 3236.
How much private Arab land did Israel’s 1953 law expropriate?
In the first year of the 1953 Land Acquisition Law, 311,000 dunams were taken from private ownership, 304,700 of them from Arab owners, according to Forman and Kedar (2004). These figures are part of the roughly 1.2 million dunams expropriated that year and are not additions to it.
How much of that land was compensated?
Forman and Kedar (2004) report that compensation had been paid for 64,500 dunams by 1959 and awarded for about 170,000 by 1970 and 198,000 by 1988. They relay these totals from Liskovski (1959), Bauml (2002) and Kretzmer (1990).
Which body did Resolution 194 make responsible for the refugees?
Resolution 194 charged the UN Conciliation Commission for Palestine with facilitating repatriation, resettlement, rehabilitation and compensation. Its Technical Committee estimated the refugee population on 7 September 1949 (United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1950).
Sources
- Fischbach, Michael R., 2003. Records of Dispossession: Palestinian Refugee Property and the Arab-Israeli Conflict. Columbia University Press, Institute for Palestine Studies Series. ISBN 9780231129787. Scholarly book.
- Forman, Geremy and Alexandre Kedar, 2004. From Arab Land to ‘Israel Lands’: The Legal Dispossession of the Palestinians Displaced by Israel in the Wake of 1948. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 22(6), 809 to 830. DOI 10.1068/d402. Peer-reviewed.
- Israel and the PLO, 1995. The Israeli-Palestinian Interim Agreement on the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. Text published by the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs. https://www.gov.il/en/Departments/General/the-israeli-palestinian-interim-agreement. Official record.
- Israel Law Review, 2018. 1948 Refugees: Proceedings of an International Workshop, Hebrew University of Jerusalem Faculty of Law, 14 to 15 December 2016. Israel Law Review 51(1), 47 to 110. DOI 10.1017/S0021223717000280. Workshop proceedings.
- Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 2009. Israel, the Conflict and Peace: Answers to Frequently Asked Questions. https://reliefweb.int/report/occupied-palestinian-territory/opt-israel-conflict-and-peace-answers-frequently-asked. Official record, a party’s own position.
- Kent, Andrew, 2012. Evaluating the Palestinians’ Claimed Right of Return. University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law 34(1), 149. scholarship.law.upenn.edu/jil/vol34/iss1/3. Law review article, not peer-reviewed.
- Lewis, Frank D., 2007. Compensation and the Abandoned Property of the 1948 Palestinian Refugees: Assessment and Implications. Explorations in Economic History 44(4), 523 to 537. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0014498306000519. Peer-reviewed, abstract-sourced.
- Mallison, W. Thomas and Sally V. Mallison, 1979. An International Law Analysis of the Major United Nations Resolutions Concerning the Palestine Question. ST/SG/SER.F/4. Study published at the request of the Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People; authors’ own views.
- Tadros, Victor, 2017. The Persistence of the Right of Return. Politics, Philosophy & Economics 16(4), 375 to 399. DOI 10.1177/1470594X17736265. Peer-reviewed, abstract-sourced.
- Tadros, Victor, 2020. Inheriting the Right of Return. Theoretical Inquiries in Law 21(2), 343 to 367. DOI 10.1515/til-2020-0017. Peer-reviewed.
- United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1950. General Progress Report and Supplementary Report. A/1367/Rev.1. https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/704900/files/A_1367_Rev-1-EN.pdf. Official record.
- United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1951. Sampling Survey of Abandoned Property Claimed by Arab Refugees. A/AC.25/W/60. https://unispal.un.org/pdfs/AAC25W60.pdf. Official record.
- United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine, 1961. Historical Survey of Efforts to Secure the Implementation of Paragraph 11 of General Assembly Resolution 194 (III): Question of Compensation. A/AC.25/W/81/Rev.2. https://unispal.un.org/pdfs/3E61557F8DE6781A052565910073E819.pdf. Official record.
- United Nations General Assembly, 1948 to 1975. Resolutions 194 (III), 3089 D (XXVIII), 3236 (XXIX), 3237 (XXIX) and 3376 (XXX), with the recorded vote on 3236, A/PV.2296, paragraph 110. documents.un.org. Official record (resolution texts and recorded vote).
