Data Reportby The Hanover InstituteNovember 16, 2026

What has a UN commission of inquiry concluded about Gaza? Five of its papers, paragraph by paragraph

A UN commission concluded in 2025 that Israel committed four of five genocide acts in Gaza. What its five papers say, about all parties, by paragraph.

What has a UN commission of inquiry concluded about Gaza? Five of its papers, paragraph by paragraph

On 16 September 2025, the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel concluded “on reasonable grounds” that Israeli authorities and security forces had committed four of the five acts listed in Article II of the Genocide Convention against Palestinians in Gaza. It also attributed State responsibility for genocide to Israel (A/HRC/60/CRP.3, paragraphs 252 and 255). The same paper records no evidence on the fifth act. It names three Israeli officials as having incited genocide and records two others as not fully assessed. In June 2024, the same Commission had concluded that members of Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups committed war crimes on 7 October 2023. Across five of its papers dated June 2024 to October 2026, the Commission’s conclusions address both Israel and Palestinian armed groups. They rest on a fact-finding standard rather than a court’s, and their territory-wide casualty totals were counted by other bodies or carry no stated source.

Key Findings

  • The Independent International Commission of Inquiry concluded on 16 September 2025, “on reasonable grounds,” that Israeli authorities and security forces committed 4 of the 5 acts listed in Article II of the Genocide Convention against Palestinians in Gaza. On the fifth act, forcibly transferring children, it recorded “no evidence” (Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, 2025, A/HRC/60/CRP.3, paragraphs 16 and 252).
  • The same paper named 3 Israeli officials as having incited genocide: President Isaac Herzog, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and then Defence Minister Yoav Gallant. It stated that it “has not fully assessed” statements by 2 other ministers (Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, 2025, paragraph 253).
  • In June 2024, the Commission concluded that members of Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups committed war crimes on 7 October 2023. In May 2026, it identified 249 cases of executions and severe violence against Palestinians in Gaza in 2024 to 2025, with at least 108 deaths, attributing the punishments to Hamas-affiliated forces (Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, 2024 to 2026, A/HRC/56/26 and A/HRC/62/22).
  • The Commission recorded that Israel gave no response to its 6 requests for information and access (Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, 2024 to 2026, A/HRC/56/26). As of 3 August 2024, the IDF Military Advocate General’s Corps reported its own count of 74 criminal investigations opened, a party’s figure not independently verified (Israel Defense Forces, Military Advocate General’s Corps, 2024).

Which genocidal acts did the commission find Israel committed?

The Commission concluded in A/HRC/60/CRP.3, dated 16 September 2025, that Israeli authorities and security forces “have committed and are continuing to commit” four of the five acts listed in Article II of the Genocide Convention against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip. It reached that conclusion “on reasonable grounds” (paragraph 252).

Article II of the Genocide Convention defines genocide as any of five acts “committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such” (Genocide Convention, 1948). Lawyers call the physical acts the actus reus. Intent is a separate element, and both must be shown.

Article II act Commission’s conclusion Paragraph
(a) Killing members of the group Committed and continuing 252
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm Committed and continuing 252
(c) Conditions of life calculated to bring about physical destruction Committed and continuing 252
(d) Measures intended to prevent births Committed and continuing 252
(e) Forcibly transferring children “No evidence” at this time 16

Source: Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, 2025, A/HRC/60/CRP.3.

On intent, the Commission held at paragraph 254 that statements by Israeli authorities “are direct evidence of genocidal intent.” It held that the pattern of conduct “is circumstantial evidence of genocidal intent and that genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference that could be drawn from the totality of the evidence.” It assessed that evidence “from 7 October 2023 until 31 July 2025” (paragraph 179).

On responsibility, paragraph 255 reads: “The Commission concludes that the State of Israel bears responsibility for the failure to prevent genocide, the commission of genocide and the failure to punish genocide against the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip.” The sentence names three separate breaches: prevention, commission and punishment. It names a State, not any individual.

When did the commission first conclude genocide, and has it repeated it?

The Commission first stated its genocide conclusion in A/HRC/60/CRP.3, dated 16 September 2025, a conference room paper to the Human Rights Council’s sixtieth session.

It repeated the conclusion in A/HRC/62/CRP.2, dated 18 June 2026. In that paper, the Commission “reiterates its conclusion” that Israeli authorities and forces “have committed the crime of genocide in Gaza” (paragraph 347).

The paper’s own words carry two points: the Commission concluded that Israel committed genocide, and it described the acts as ongoing. Paragraph 252 uses the phrase “have committed and are continuing to commit.” The June 2026 paper restates the conclusion rather than withdrawing it. A/81/430, the advance unedited report of 14 October 2026, states at paragraph 54 that Israeli authorities and forces “continue to commit genocidal acts with the genocidal intent to destroy, in whole or in part, the Palestinians in Gaza.”

The document type affects how the conclusion should be described. A/HRC/60/CRP.3 is a 72-page conference room paper marked “English only.” A commission established by Human Rights Council resolution S-30/1 submitted it. The paper is the Commission’s own legal analysis. It is not a numbered report of the Council, and no member State voted to adopt it.

The June 2026 reiteration is worded act by act. A/HRC/62/CRP.2 is a paper on Palestinian children titled “The essence of childhood has been destroyed.” Its paragraph 347 restates the conclusion through two acts, “killing and causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group, including Palestinian children.” Paragraph 351 separately “reiterates its finding” that Israeli authorities and security forces deliberately inflicted conditions of life calculated to bring about physical destruction.

Source: Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel, 2025; and 2024 to 2026.

Fifteen months separate the Commission’s first Gaza conclusions, in June 2024, from the genocide paper. Those earlier conclusions are set out below, in the section on what the Commission had concluded before genocide.

Which of the Convention’s five acts did the commission not find?

In A/HRC/60/CRP.3 of 16 September 2025, the Commission recorded that it had no evidence on one of the Convention’s five acts: “At this time, the Commission has no evidence in relation to the fifth category of act, forcibly transferring children” (paragraph 16). The other four acts are the ones it concluded were committed.

The qualifier “at this time” is the Commission’s own. Article II(e) of the Convention lists “forcibly transferring children of the group to another group” as the fifth act (Genocide Convention, 1948). The paper records that its evidence, assessed up to 31 July 2025, contained nothing on that category.

Paragraph 251 sets two further limits. First, the analysis “relates solely to the determination of genocide under the Genocide Convention as it relates to the responsibility of the State of Israel.” Second, it is “limited to the Palestinians specifically in Gaza during the period since 7 October 2023.” The paper is therefore a conclusion on State responsibility, not a finding of individual criminal guilt. It also covers no territory outside the Gaza Strip.

On the West Bank, the same paragraph states that the analysis “nevertheless raises the serious concern” that genocidal intent “has extended to the rest of the occupied Palestinian territory.” The Commission framed this as a concern, not a conclusion. Its later West Bank conclusions appear in A/81/430, dated 14 October 2026 and issued as an advance unedited version. Those conclusions are framed as crimes against humanity, including extermination and persecution, rather than as genocide.

The June 2026 reiteration keeps the same geographic limit. A/HRC/62/CRP.2, paragraph 347, places the crime of genocide “in Gaza” and names two acts. Across both papers, the territory is the Gaza Strip and the period begins on 7 October 2023. The transfer of children is the act on which the September 2025 paper recorded no evidence, and the June 2026 paper does not address it.

Which Israeli officials did the commission say incited genocide?

The Commission named three Israeli officials in A/HRC/60/CRP.3 of 16 September 2025 as having incited genocide. Paragraph 253 reads: “Israeli President Isaac Herzog, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and then Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, have incited the commission of genocide.” Each official is named in the public role the Commission attached to him.

The same paragraph limits the list. The Commission “has not fully assessed” statements by Ministers Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich, so the paper makes no incitement conclusion about either. Three officials are concluded to have incited genocide. The other two are recorded as not fully assessed.

Under the Convention, incitement is punishable in its own right. Article III(c) lists “direct and public incitement to commit genocide” among the acts punishable alongside genocide itself (Genocide Convention, 1948). In the Commission’s paper, the officials’ statements serve two purposes. Paragraph 253 treats them as incitement, and paragraph 254 treats statements by Israeli authorities as “direct evidence of genocidal intent.”

Incitement had already appeared in a court order. On 26 January 2024, in South Africa v. Israel, the International Court of Justice voted sixteen to one, on a seventeen-member bench, for a provisional measure on incitement. The measure reads: “The State of Israel shall … take all measures within its power to prevent and punish the direct and public incitement to commit genocide in relation to members of the Palestinian group in the Gaza Strip.” Israel’s judge ad hoc, Aharon Barak, voted in favour. An order of this kind requires preventive steps. It does not find that incitement occurred.

Like the rest of the paper, the incitement conclusion concerns State responsibility. The International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants on 21 November 2024 for two of the three officials, Netanyahu and Gallant. Those warrants name war crimes and crimes against humanity, and neither genocide nor incitement to genocide is among them.

What did the commission conclude about Hamas and October 7?

The Commission concluded in A/HRC/56/26, dated 14 June 2024, that on 7 October 2023 members of the military wings of Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups “deliberately killed, injured, mistreated, took hostages and committed sexual and gender-based violence against civilians.” It added: “These actions constitute war crimes and violations and abuses of international humanitarian law and international human rights law” (paragraph 90).

Paragraph 90 attributes those acts both to members of the armed groups and to Palestinian civilians who directly participated. The paper covers conduct “between 7 October and 31 December 2023.”

On one question, the Commission recorded that it could not reach a conclusion. Paragraph 95 states that it “did not find credible evidence, however, that militants had received orders to commit sexual violence and was thus unable to reach a conclusion on the issue.” The open question is whether orders were given. Paragraph 90 already lists sexual and gender-based violence among the acts committed.

The same paper examined Israeli conduct on 7 October. Paragraph 96 records that Israeli forces “applied the ‘Hannibal Directive’, killing at least 14 Israeli civilians.”

The Commission returned to Hamas in its May 2026 paper on non-State actors. Paragraph 82 of A/HRC/62/22, dated 8 May 2026, identifies “249 individual cases of executions and severe physical violence inflicted on Palestinians in Gaza” in 2024 to 2025, “resulting in at least 108 deaths and 384 injuries.” The Commission considers that this “likely represents only a partial number.” The victims in those cases are Palestinians, and the paper attributes the punishments to “Hamas-affiliated forces.”

Two court records cover related ground. On 21 November 2024, the International Criminal Court’s Pre-Trial Chamber I issued a warrant for Mohammed Diab Ibrahim Al-Masri (Deif), whom the Chamber described as the highest commander of Hamas’s al-Qassam Brigades. The warrant names crimes including murder, extermination, hostage-taking, and rape and other forms of sexual violence. The Chamber terminated proceedings on 26 February 2025 after the Prosecution notified it of his death. The International Court of Justice, in its 26 January 2024 order, stated that it was “gravely concerned about the fate of the hostages” held by “Hamas and other armed groups.” It called for their “immediate and unconditional release.”

What had the commission concluded about Gaza before genocide?

In A/HRC/56/26, dated 14 June 2024, the Commission examined conduct between 7 October and 31 December 2023. It concluded that “Israel has committed war crimes, crimes against humanity and violations of international humanitarian law and international human rights law” (paragraph 97). The paper frames its conclusions in those categories rather than as genocide.

Paragraph 102 adds a specific conclusion on food: “Israel has used starvation as a method of war”; “This is a war crime.” The same paper also carries the conclusions against Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups described above. Its findings therefore address both parties for the same 12-week period.

The September 2025 paper added a conclusion under a different instrument rather than replacing these categories. The Genocide Convention requires intent to destroy a protected group in whole or in part. War crimes and crimes against humanity are defined without that element. The earlier conclusions therefore stood beside the later one; they were not steps toward it.

The Commission has continued to use the earlier categories since September 2025. A/81/430 is its fifth report to the General Assembly, dated 14 October 2026 and issued as an advance unedited version whose paragraph numbers and wording may change. At paragraph 61, it concludes that “Israeli authorities and forces committed age-based persecution against Palestinian children in the West Bank, as they did in Gaza, which is a crime against humanity.”

The starvation conclusion also appears in a criminal court’s record. On 21 November 2024, the International Criminal Court’s Pre-Trial Chamber I issued warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu, Prime Minister at the time of the relevant conduct, and Yoav Gallant, then Minister of Defence. The warrants name “the war crime of starvation as a method of warfare” among the crimes. They were issued on the arrest-warrant standard of reasonable grounds to believe. No trial has occurred, and the persons named are suspects.

Does the commission’s genocide finding carry a court’s force?

The Commission’s genocide conclusion of 16 September 2025 rests on two standards it states itself. Its standard of proof is “reasonable grounds” (paragraph 252). For intent, it applies the International Court of Justice’s “only reasonable inference” test (paragraphs 179 and 254). Paragraph 251 confines the paper to “the responsibility of the State of Israel.” The conclusion is a fact-finding body’s, not a court judgment.

Each part of that frame comes from the Commission’s own text. “Reasonable grounds” is a fact-finding threshold. The “only reasonable inference” test is the standard the International Court of Justice applies when inferring genocidal intent from a pattern of conduct.

The court hearing the case under the same Convention has not reached that question. In South Africa’s case against Israel, the International Court of Justice stated at paragraph 30 of its order of 26 January 2024 that it “is not required to ascertain whether any violations of Israel’s obligations under the Genocide Convention have occurred.” Such a finding, it said, could be made “only at the stage of the examination of the merits.” What the Court found plausible, at paragraph 54, was “the right of the Palestinians in Gaza to be protected from acts of genocide and related prohibited acts.” It also found plausible South Africa’s right to seek Israel’s compliance with the Convention. Paragraph 83 states that the Court’s provisional measures “have binding effect.”

The criminal court has not charged genocide. The International Criminal Court’s warrants of 21 November 2024 for Netanyahu and Gallant name four sets of crimes:

  • the war crime of starvation as a method of warfare;
  • the war crime of intentionally directing an attack against the civilian population;
  • the crimes against humanity of murder and persecution;
  • the crime against humanity of other inhumane acts.

For the period to 20 May 2024, the Chamber “could not determine that all elements of the crime against humanity of extermination were met.” On 24 April 2025, the Appeals Chamber reversed the Pre-Trial Chamber’s decision on Israel’s article 19(2) jurisdiction challenge. It sent the matter back for a new ruling on the substance.

Three bodies have applied three standards:

  • The Commission found reasonable grounds on State responsibility.
  • The International Court of Justice found the rights plausible and has not yet reached the merits.
  • The International Criminal Court found reasonable grounds to believe, the standard for arrest.

Of the three records, only the Commission’s states genocide as a conclusion.

Did Israel answer the commission’s requests for information?

The Commission recorded in A/HRC/56/26 of 14 June 2024 that it sent six “requests for information and access to the Government of Israel.” It also recorded: “No response was received from the Government of Israel.” The record of non-response appears in the Commission’s first Gaza paper, which covers conduct up to 31 December 2023.

Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs published its legal framework on 2 November 2023, before the Commission’s first Gaza paper. The framework states the standard Israel applies to its own conduct. It is a party’s statement of its legal position. It is neither a reply to the Commission nor a finding of compliance.

The framework states: “If the attack results in more collateral damage than expected, this does not necessarily indicate a violation: compliance is conduct-oriented, not result-oriented.” It adds that “Estimating expected civilian harm can be very challenging, especially when operating in a complex and dense urban environment where civilian presence is dynamic and often hard to ascertain.”

On distinction between combatants and civilians, the Ministry states that “the IDF only targets persons who are members of organized armed groups or civilians directly participating in the hostilities.” On treaty status, it states that Israel “abides by all applicable rules of customary international law, including those embodied in conventions to which it is not a party (such as the 1977 Additional Protocols to the Geneva Conventions).” On legal review, it states that “IDF legal advisers are not subject to the IDF chain of command on professional matters, but report directly to the Military Advocate General.”

On warnings, the same document states that the IDF has “in some cases made individual phone-calls to occupants of targets, warning them of impending attacks.” It says that where circumstances do not permit a warning, “there is no legal requirement to do so.” It also states that “the IDF does not assume that there are no civilians in areas or sites where advance warnings had been given.”

Israel did file reports with the International Court of Justice. The Court’s later orders record reports filed by Israel on 26 February 2024 and 29 April 2024 under the reporting measures. The contents of those reports are not published in the orders.

Which conduct has Israel’s military investigated, on its own count?

The IDF Military Advocate General’s Corps reported that, as of 3 August 2024, it had opened 74 criminal investigations into conduct in the Gaza war. This is the IDF’s own count, published by a party to the events and not independently verified. The count covers investigations opened, not findings, indictments or convictions.

On the Corps’ breakdown, 44 of the 74 investigations concern the deaths of detainees held by the IDF and 13 concern pillaging or stealing. Eight concern alleged detainee mistreatment, 6 alleged illegal use of force, and 3 alleged destruction of civilian property without military necessity. The five categories sum to 74.

Source: Israel Defense Forces, Military Advocate General’s Corps, 2024; a party’s own count, not independently verified.

The Corps also reported, on its own count, that over 1,000 incidents had been referred to the General Staff’s Fact-Finding and Assessment Mechanism. Hundreds were still under assessment at the time of writing. The Mechanism was created during the 2014 Gaza conflict on a recommendation of the Turkel Commission.

The investigation count depends on the threshold the Corps applies. In the Corps’ words, civilian death or injury, “while tragic and regrettable, in most cases do not by themselves indicate a reasonable suspicion of criminal conduct, as they can be explained as reasonable aftermath of lawful operational activity.” On independence, the Corps states that the Military Advocate General “is subject only to the law on professional matters and operates with full independence.” Its decisions can be challenged before Israel’s Attorney General and Supreme Court.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs FAQ of 8 December 2023 gives Israel’s own cumulative minimum figures for warnings, as reported by a party to the conflict:

  • over 15 million text messages;
  • over 12 million pre-recorded phone calls;
  • over 4.5 million leaflets;
  • over 45,000 individual phone calls.

The four channels cannot be added together into a count of warnings or of people warned.

Whose casualty counts stand behind the commission’s figures?

The Commission’s figure of 20,179 children killed in Gaza between 7 October 2023 and 7 October 2025 appears in A/HRC/62/CRP.2, paragraph 26.

Its footnote 29 attributes that count to OCHA situation update 329 and to the Gaza Ministry of Health’s Telegram channel. The count therefore belongs to those bodies, not to the Commission. The same paragraph and footnote carry 44,143 children injured over the same period, counted by the same two bodies.

A/81/430, the advance unedited report, states at paragraph 59 that “over 75,000” Palestinians across the whole occupied territory have been killed since 7 October 2023. That figure carries no footnote, so the body that counted it is not stated, and it is not a count the Commission records as its own.

The same CRP.2 paragraph states that those children made up 30% of those killed and 26% of those injured during the period. Those shares are of totals drawn from the same relayed sources.

The Gaza count has its own publisher. The Ministry of Health in Gaza is a party to the war, and its figures are its own count, not independently verified. Its daily report of 10 September 2026 gave 73,670 cumulative deaths. Its Health Annual Report, Palestine 2025 gives children as 30% of 71,271 deaths from 2023 to the end of 2025. The ministry has stated its own exclusions since 7 January 2024. It does not count:

  • the missing and those under rubble;
  • unidentified bodies;
  • burials by families outside hospitals;
  • deaths in Gaza and North Gaza after its information system stopped in November 2023.

Its name-by-name lists record each person’s date of birth, not date of death.

The “over 75,000” in A/81/430 covers the whole occupied Palestinian territory as of October 2026. The ministry’s 73,670 covers Gaza alone, as of September 2026. The two figures have different scopes and dates, and neither can be subtracted from the other to produce a third count.

Methodology and limitations

The Independent International Commission of Inquiry’s five papers dated 14 June 2024 to 14 October 2026 form the core record: A/HRC/56/26, A/HRC/60/CRP.3, A/HRC/62/22, A/HRC/62/CRP.2 and A/81/430. Each was read in full text and is quoted by paragraph number. Two are conference room papers rather than numbered reports. A/81/430 is an advance unedited version, so its paragraph numbers and wording may change in the final text. The Commission’s standard of proof throughout is “reasonable grounds.” The genocide paper assesses evidence up to 31 July 2025.

Court records are cited for what they state and for their recorded votes, never as evidence of conduct. From the International Court of Justice, these are the order of 26 January 2024 and the later orders of 28 March and 24 May 2024. From the International Criminal Court, these are the decisions of 21 November 2024 and the Appeals Chamber rulings of 24 April and 15 December 2025. The ICC warrants are classified, so the crimes listed here come from the Chamber’s public summary. The documents read contain no record of the Pre-Trial Chamber’s new ruling on the remanded article 19(2) challenge. Israel’s reports to the International Court of Justice are not published in its orders.

The Israeli government sources are:

  • the Ministry of Foreign Affairs legal framework of 2 November 2023;
  • the Ministry of Foreign Affairs FAQ of 8 December 2023;
  • the Military Advocate General’s Corps account, updated 3 August 2024.

Each is labelled as a party’s own position or count. The Gaza Ministry of Health’s figures are likewise a party’s own count. The ministry publishes them only through its media office channel. Its list documents were read from an archived copy whose record counts and columns match the ministry’s own description.

Every casualty figure in the Commission’s papers is attributed to the body named in the papers’ footnotes. Where a paper carries no footnote, the measuring body is stated as unknown.

Conclusion

So what has the Independent International Commission of Inquiry concluded about Gaza? In September 2025, it concluded on reasonable grounds that Israel committed genocide there through four of the Convention’s five acts, and it said so again in June and October 2026.

Around that sentence, the record is wider and more specific:

  • Acts: the Commission found four acts and recorded no evidence on the fifth.
  • Incitement: it named three officials as having incited genocide and recorded two as not fully assessed.
  • Hamas: it concluded that Hamas and other armed groups committed war crimes on 7 October 2023, and it counted at least 108 Palestinians killed in the cases it identified for 2024 to 2025, attributing them to Hamas-affiliated forces.
  • Earlier conclusions: its June 2024 paper concluded that Israel committed war crimes and crimes against humanity and used starvation as a method of war.
  • Israel’s response: Israel did not answer six requests from the Commission. It did publish its own legal standard and its own count of 74 criminal investigations opened, a party’s figure not independently verified.
  • Casualty counts: the children the Commission lists as killed were counted by OCHA and by the Gaza ministry, itself a party to the war. The Commission did not measure them.

The Commission used the word genocide on a fact-finding threshold. The court applying the same Convention has not reached the merits, and the criminal court’s warrants name no genocide. When three records carry one word at three different standards, which of them should public debate treat as the conclusion? And what would the record need to contain before those three standards point to the same answer?

Frequently Asked Questions

Which body created the commission?

The Human Rights Council established the Commission by resolution S-30/1. Its mandate covers the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel. Its papers go to the Council, and its annual reports, such as A/81/430, go to the General Assembly.

What does “actus reus” mean in the genocide paper?

Actus reus is the physical element of a crime: here, the five acts listed in Article II of the Genocide Convention of 1948. Genocide also requires a mental element, the intent to destroy a protected group in whole or in part. The Commission treats intent separately at paragraph 254.

What did the commission conclude about settler violence?

In A/HRC/62/22 of 8 May 2026, paragraph 76, the Commission concluded that Israel’s conduct “in allowing settler violence to continue unabated, and colluding in the commission of violence, is in breach of its obligations to protect Palestinians under the Fourth Geneva Convention.” That paper covered killing and harm by non-State actors on both sides.

Why were the ICJ’s provisional measures all addressed to Israel?

All eleven measures across the International Court of Justice’s three 2024 orders are addressed to the State of Israel. The Court gave a jurisdictional reason at paragraph 44 of its 28 March 2024 order. Under Article 59 of its Statute, it can indicate measures only “to be taken by the parties, but not by third States or other entities,” and Israel and South Africa are the only parties. In its reasoning, the Court repeatedly called on Hamas and other armed groups to release the hostages.

What happened to Israel’s challenges at the ICC?

On 15 December 2025, by majority, the International Criminal Court’s Appeals Chamber confirmed the Pre-Trial Chamber’s article 18(1) ruling that no new notification to Israel was required. The Appeals Chamber had earlier reversed the article 19(2) jurisdiction decision and sent it back. Israel was still filing arguments on that challenge on 1 August 2025.

Does the Gaza ministry’s list record when each person died?

The ministry’s list documents of March, June and August 2024 carry date of birth, not date of death. The ministry’s own statement of 29 July 2024 explains that the date was recorded on the family’s report or on the date the body reached a hospital, and that a committee was then formed to audit it. These are a party’s own statements about its own records, not independently verified.

Is the commission’s genocide conclusion binding on any State?

A/HRC/60/CRP.3 is a conference room paper. The Commission submitted it to the Human Rights Council, and no member State voted to adopt it. The binding effect described at paragraph 83 of the International Court of Justice’s order of 26 January 2024 attaches to that Court’s provisional measures, not to the Commission’s papers.

Sources

Related research